Today, April 14 2024, I finished recording my new album, Capistrano.  The album runs 38 minutes and 40 seconds.

I started working on the album on November 23, 2014 so that means that this one album of 39-ish minutes of music took me a grand total of 9 years, 4 months, and 23 days to create meaning this is officially the longest gestated album I’ve ever worked on, beating The Lavone’s 1999 album “The Hiatus” by about three years.

There is still mixing and mastering to do, artwork to create, etc., but no more recording.  I tracked the last bits this afternoon and made the first test mix of the album and just listened to it twice.  I pronounce it good.  I will attempt to take less time on the next one but apparently this is what needed to happen for this one to be born.  To quote Captain Kirk, “Who am I to argue with history?”

For 30 years I’ve made my living in this world, paid my bills and my taxes, raised my kid, almost entirely from the writing of computer software.  It’s a solid skill, always in demand, and I’m good at it.  Both before and throughout that entire professional career I have also had a (far less lucrative but infinitely more satisfying) shadow career as an independent musician, writer, filmmaker and creator.  I have a resume that details the technology career, but not really one that details my career as a creator.  This is that resume.  Kind of…

I was born into a family of musicians and singers and raised with access to instruments and primitive recording technology but never had any formal training with two exceptions: I played french horn in school band for a few months in elementary school and I took a 6-week crash course in guitar when I was 12.  I didn’t consider that music was something that required training if you had an ear, and I had that, so, I figured I could work it out for myself.

Music was not my first creative passion.  The first was visual art.  I liked to draw and paint.  My mom was a singer in a band and my dad painted wildlife watercolors and could draw exceptionally well so I had my pick of parents to emulate and older brother Rhett was already obsessed with music so I wound up glued to my sketchbook.   As I got a little older I decided that even though I was good at drawing and enjoyed it what I really wanted to be was a writer.

By early adolescence I had broadened my interests still further, having taught myself how to write software for the home computers of the era and also having developed a rabid obsession with cars.  The first three years after I bought my first guitar I rarely practiced and was much more interested in the 0-60 times of the Porsche 959 and drawing and designing imaginary cars than I was in music making.  Then puberty hit and some switch in my brain went musical.

Rhett and I had our band, The Lavone, and we had recorded a lot of music, but I was a fairly passive participant until suddenly I wasn’t.  I started having musical ideas and interests and really learning what to do with them around the age of 15.  I upgraded my guitar and got some cool glasses and turned into one of those High School Art Kids.

Visual arts and explorations into videography and photography were of nearly as much interest as the music.  When I was in high school I was always creating one thing or another.  I wrote a few bad novels, created sculptures and jewelry and pottery and learned basic woodworking, made some paintings, all the usual stuff that a teenager does to look for ways to express themselves.  Rhett and I started our little basement record label, Nuclear Gopher, and music became a core part of my identity even as I started doing less writing, less painting, less drawing, etc.

Post high-school I got married and my time for creative work trended downward but my need for it didn’t.  I started coming up with ways to give myself excuses to keep recording albums with The Lavone and creating visual art even as my software engineering career began.  Since the internet was a new phenomenon at the time, that meant building a website for the Nuclear Gopher as well as making music videos and short films.  I can honestly say, however, that my 20’s were a period of creative challenge.  I made some great songs with The Lavone and the Nuclear Gopher turned into it’s own amazing thing, but I found a role for myself as more of a producer, a technician, a documenter, an archivist, and an enabler than as a musician.

As I was approaching 30 I was getting nervous that the life of a creative person was becoming too inaccessible for me.  I had a young child to raise, my other career was time consuming, and I often wondered if I was just deluding myself that I had anything worth creating inside me.  I started to turn my attention more towards filmmaking and writing.  I taught myself digital video editing and the basics of cinematography.  I made some shorts and started planning to make an indie feature film.

But, as John Lennon once sang, life is what happens to you while you’re busy making other plans.  My 30’s started with the general disruption of my entire family, life, and self.  A lost religion, a failed marriage, and estrangement from my family and friends.  I had nothing really to fall back on except music.

I realized that I wanted to, NEEDED to, make music, and I started my solo music career at the grand old age of 30.

At first I had a lot to learn.  Despite spending over half my life in and around bands and recording studios, I had never really engineered or produced my own music.  I could play guitar and sing but I couldn’t drum worth a damn and keyboards were a mystery.  Regardless, I tracked an album that I didn’t share with anybody and then I tracked an EP called The Context in 2004 and then my first proper album, Songs of Be Redoubt, the following year.  I wrote the songs, engineered the tracks, played all the instruments, designed the cover art, mixed and mastered it, the whole thing was a learning process.  By the end of working on Bo Redoubt, I was quite a bit better at the whole solo music making thing but I was still missing some of the polish that would come from playing in a band that had regular practices, live shows, and opportunities to hone my skills.

An opportunity soon arose to do so and I decided to join a band called The Eclectics, a Unitarian Universalist church band that played at Sunday services.  I played the guitar and sang, we played in front of the congregation, and after a year or so I was feeling a lot more confident musically.  In February of 2007 this lead to the formation of my (to date only) post-Lavone band, Trumpet Marine with three other members of The Eclectics.  We tracked an album called Longer, Louder, Lobster and it was arguably the best thing I had ever done up to that point.  I felt like I had arrived, at least a little, enough to try my hand at fronting the band on stage for some gigs.

Trumpet Marine was short lived, however.  Competing commitments caused members to come and go, we were constantly relearning the songs with new people, I just couldn’t hold it together and by early 2009 I gave up the idea.  I had recorded another solo album in the meantime and it was…  OK… but I was not yet a confident musical artist.

The next year or two involved some personal drama and my bandwidth was once again limited to really reach for what I wanted to do musically.  I was almost ready to give up on music but then I wrote a song called “I Sleep With My Hands In Fists” and it rallied me to get up off the mat and come out swinging again.  I had my studio and I was recording and writing, I had also played here and there in another few short lived bands, but it wasn’t clicking.  If I wanted to get things to click I needed to change something.

In early 2012 I struck some creative gold with an album called Blood and Scotch/Valentine, which I tracked in a couple of weeks all on my own.  I even broke out the art supplies and painted the cover, a bright yellow heart amidst a haze of chaos.  I knew I didn’t want to give up after that record.  I just didn’t know exactly what happened next.

I remembered that playing in other bands had helped me develop my skills and increase my passion for music so I decided to try that again.  I joined a local Ween-meets-Devo group called Robots From the Future as their keyboardist despite being pretty bad at keys.  I figured I wouldn’t get better unless I had a good reason to do so.  We played shows and practiced and I did get better.  There was no real pressure because I wasn’t the front man and they weren’t my songs.  I could just focus on playing.  Robots music wasn’t really my best fit, though, so I left the band and started making plans for the album I really wanted to make.  I had a sort of “back to basics” idea where I would record a few short EPs and then get serious about making a record that I would be totally happy with.  I figured that might take me a year or two.  I released the first of the EPs, The Coal Room, on Christmas of 2014.

I also joined another band, a 90’s cover band called Fistful of Datas, but this time on bass guitar and occasional auxiliary keys.  One of the Robots, Keith Lodermeier, was in that band and through that band I also met some other fantastic people, his wife Liz, Cris Arias-Romero, Maya Burroughs, and Mackenzie Lahren.  Another one of the Robots, Reynold Kissling, came on board near the tail end of my tenure with the group.

During the couple of years I played with that band I had a blast, met a lot of people, and improved my skills but that solo album I had committed to sort of went into development hell.  I just didn’t have the time to devote to solo studio work while also living the grown up life of a married career man in his 40’s.  I was having fun but I wasn’t creative.  Somehow the years were slipping by without much progress, even though I kept locking myself in the studio now and then.

I played a solo set at a now defunct space in St. Paul to try out some of my new album material in front of an audience and that led to an invite to join yet another band, Awkward Bodies, as a bass player.  The music of Awkward Bodies was definitely more up my alley than 90’s cover songs so I was really excited to join them and more shows followed.  Things were going pretty good and my spirits were high, I thought I might finally get my new album done, but then John Lennon happened again.

I don’t know what it was, exactly, but the world seemed to go nuts starting in 2016.  An orange sociopath was somehow put in power in my country and I became too obsessed with the fallout.  Social media and podcasts and news feeds and negativity took over my headspace.  My creative output dwindled to nearly nothing, despite having a great studio sitting in my own damn basement.  At least I was playing in Awkward Bodies and enjoying that but musically I was closer than I had ever been to hanging it up.  The world seemed too stupid to want to create within it.  It seemed like every day there was some outrage or insanity and playing cool indie rock was just not enough.  My software career had changed from writing code to running the department so I spent none of my day doing hands-on work, instead getting enmeshed in emails and meetings and exhaustion.

Then something weird happened in 2018.  A filmmaker named Scott Homan contacted me about telling my story for a documentary.  We met.  I told him my story.  I had no expectation that this would lead anywhere bigger than a short on YouTube, if that.  I didn’t know him or how serious and committed he turned out to be.  That event changed my life.

The world descended further into chaos with a global pandemic and my beloved Minneapolis being torn apart in the wake of the George Floyd riots.  Awkward Bodies struggled to hold the band together and keep some sort of momentum.  I continued to struggle to find personal creative traction.  But Scott and his editor, Sian Walmsley, just kept hacking away at making a movie and as it took shape I started to see my creative career differently.  It had not been a success but had also not been a failure.  I had struggled, sure, but so does everybody else who creates.  I was no longer in my 20’s but I had improved at every aspect of making music and art in the meantime.  And, most importantly, I had made a positive difference in the world with Nuclear Gopher and with my writing and my art.  When I saw the movie for the first time I woke up and knew what I needed to do.  I saw a possible future.  Not commercially, but artistically.  And I felt inspired again.

I got serious about finishing my slowly developing album.  I started planning for a new chapter in the Nuclear Gopher story.  I came to the realization that my time spent wandering in the creative wilderness, taking my licks, getting better at my craft, making mistakes, failing at plans, meeting people, playing Spice Girls covers while dressed as a zombie, and just generally living my life had made me stronger and more self-aware.  Sure, I’m older now, oldest I’ve ever been, but I’m not slow, I’m not tired, I’m not out of ideas, and I’m not ready to hang it up, not just yet.

The last couple of years have involved a LOT of work below the waterline.  Renovated my studio for future commercial use, making plans for the new Gopher, several revisions of the album (which is now practically done), and a new attitude towards the work I am doing that has really put me in a good place mentally.

My creative career could be counted in how many albums I’ve contributed to, how many shows I’ve played, how many films and videos I’ve made, etc, but I don’t even know the answers to those questions.  I guess I don’t care or I would keep track.  What I do know is that I’ve been dedicated to a life of making whatever art I can manage for as long as I can remember and for helping others do the same.  That’s my career.  That’s what I want to be remembered for when I die.  If nothing else, I’m leaving behind artifacts that prove I was here and that I did my best.  What else can a person do?

Skills and Experience:

I have demonstrated proficiency with:

  • audio engineering and production (both digital and analog)
  • digital video editing using Final Cut Pro and Davinci Resolve
  • guitar, bass, drums, keyboards, vocals, and other instruments
  • photography (both film and digital)
  • graphic design, painting, drawing
  • website development
  • writing

Salary Requirements:

Happiness.

People occasionally ask me about how Nuclear Gopher happened.  There is sometimes a sort of wonder that even though Rhett and I were two nice Jehovah’s Witness kids from the neighborhood we started this crazy experimental band and then an underground record label.  The assumption seems to be that we must have been rebels or trying to stir things up or “be worldly”, in Witness lingo.  Honestly, though, this couldn’t be further from the truth.

Nuclear Gopher has deep roots that go back to before I was even born and one thing led to another and another until that seemed like a natural outcome.  I usually tell people that music is the family business.  Here’s a bit about that, with some multimedia accompaniment.

I can trace the family business back at least as far as our maternal grandparents, Joseph and Ethelwynn (Hineline) Brunette.

My Grandparents
My grandparents, Joseph Brunette and Ethelwynn (Hineline) Brunette

That’s them in the pic, below is the two of them singing a beautiful rendition of the song “Drifting and Dreaming”.  Give it a listen.  It’s gorgeous.

The Brunette Family
The Brunette family, the early years. My mom hadn’t come along yet.

The Brunette clan was a big, boisterous, musically gifted, Catholic family with thirteen children, of whom my mom was the tenth in line.  Grandpa Brunette played guitar and sang, Grandma played the banjo and sang, and all the kids were taught to sing at an early age, often into a microphone connected to a reel-to-reel tape recorder and sometimes they even sang on local radio programs.  It was one of the main family past times and that’s how our mom spent her childhood.

Here’s a 1956 radio appearance by The Brunette Children singing “Gonna Get Along Without You” and “Ringo Rango”:

Mom experienced two major tragedies when she was young.  First, she lost her father when she was only nine years old.  Then, when she was eighteen, she lost her then fifteen year old brother Jerry in a car accident.  Those two loses made a major mark on her.

Jerry Brunette
Jerry Brunette

Mom was a shy girl, very pretty, and a helluva singer.  In another life she could have been Cher.  But she told me many times that she had always felt lost, like she was adrift in life, never given a chance to properly grow up.  She got married almost immediately out of high school and became a mother to my brother Rhett not long after.  When I was born fourteen months later my mom had just had her twentieth birthday.  That’s a lot for a young person to live through.  I think about how she must have felt, only twenty years old and already a mother of two, married to a man she hadn’t known for long, still mourning her brother and father… It makes sense to me that the message of the Jehovah’s Witnesses appealed to her at that time.  I can understand why she listened when her neighbor told her about the last days and an interpretation of the Bible that was entirely new to her Catholic trained mind.  I can likewise understand why she clung to music.  That was her lifeline, her connection to her past.  To quote my dear friend Cindy Elvendahl, music was her savior.

My mom’s senior photo

She and her brother Rick had formed a band called Special Export.  It was a cover band, they played at supper clubs and parties and wedding receptions.  Over the years the band went through various iterations, name changes, and phases, but it was always there when Rhett and I were growing up.  Even as Rhett and I (and later Reed and Robbie) were being taken to meetings at the Kingdom Hall and raised as Witnesses, we also attended band practices and gigs.  Mom was always the star of the show.  She didn’t play any instruments but she was this glamorous lead singer and people were always so impressed by her voice and, man, it was like living with a celebrity.  Of COURSE we wanted to do it too.

Here is mom with her gold microphone singing “Girl From Ipanema” in the late 80’s.

It’s hard to remember a time in my life, even as early as four years old, where Rhett and I weren’t trying to make music.  We had a record player and a bunch of hand me down albums and we sang along to The Beatles and Barry Manilow and Grand Funk Railroad until we were sent to bed.  We pretended to be rock stars, we drummed with pencils on the furniture, we planned gigs and put on little shows for any audience we could find, neighbors, our parents, or the other kids in the home daycare that mom ran for extra money.  I have a sign hanging in the Nuclear Gopher studio from a “concert” we put on as The Rockboys when I was six years old.

The Rockboys Show Poster
Our first show poster.

Rhett started sitting in on drums with mom’s band at paid gigs when he was 7.  I bought my first electric guitar at 12.  Like I said, the roots run deep.  And a little “derp”.

Rhett was so good at drums at such an early age that he attracted the attention of a group of young adults from a nearby congregation who, like my mom, were forming a cover band to play weddings and the like.  The others in the band were all in their 20’s but they brought the little 12 year old drummer into the group because he was really really really really good and he could also sing.

Rhett gets a present from his Hubcaps and Hearts bandmates

It was a 50’s band called Hubcaps and Hearts and when Rhett joined, they decided to use the Sutter home as their practice space.  This was great because we had a room in the basement that we had been using as our “music room” ever since The Rockboys.  There had been a drum set in there for five years but suddenly there was more.  Guitars, amps, microphones, keyboards, speakers, it was real gear, gear we could never have afforded, and it was just sitting there most of the time.  Of COURSE we recorded music with it.  That had been one of our primary hobbies for years and now we could try to do it on another level.

Rhett, Reed, and I were calling ourselves ROW at the time.  We always had a penchant for picking band names that were people pronounced wrong and in this case ROW was supposed to be like the British word for a fight not like something you do with an oar in a boat but I digress.  The sudden access to equipment caused the three of us to record our first album as ROW which we called “Terror Again” and it was a blast but Rhett and I struggled a bit with Reed.

“Waldo Koterman” by ROW

It wasn’t Reed’s fault, he is a brilliant and amazing person, an awesome kid brother, and he later became a spectacular musical recording artist but at the time I was 12, Rhett was 13, but Reed was only 9 and he didn’t know how to play any instruments.  Rather than wait for him to catch up, Rhett and I chose to start a new band with just the two of us.  We called ourselves The Lavone (another pronunciation problem for most people, it’s meant to be pronounced like “love own” but people usually pronounce it “love on”, whatever…) and that was the fateful moment.  The Lavone started in 1986 and was never officially “broken up” although our last recording session was in 2003 and Rhett died in 2005, ending it for good.

How it started:

The Lavone, 1986

“My Adventure Flowerland” – 1986

…  and how it ended up:

The Lavone’s final show, 2000

“Blues Around My Soul” – 2000

Nuclear Gopher exists because The Lavone existed.  The Lavone existed because of mom, and grandpa, and ROW, and The Rockboys, and Hubcaps and Hearts, and me and Rhett sharing a bedroom and a brain, and all of that stuff that came before.

For the first three years of The Lavone we made albums and in early 1989 I recorded a song called The Gay Laughter of Nuclear Gophers, a title I found written on a slip of paper while cleaning my bedroom one day.  I vaguely remember waking up from a dream and scribbling it down in the middle of the night but I don’t remember the dream.  It randomly happened to be the most recent song I had recorded before Rhett and I bought our first 4-track recorder so the words “Nuclear Gopher” were fresh in our minds when we christened our studio and the label just stuck after that.

It’s not a particularly great song.  It was just this sort of  guitar experiment that I recorded.  The idea was to use a brass slide in a sort of bowing technique to create an ambient soundscape and various forms of tapping to make something synthesizer-esque using only a guitar.  In case you want to here it, here it is, “The Gay Laughter of Nuclear Gophers” by The Lavone from January of 1989, the accidental namesake of the whole kit and kaboodle.

So, there you go.  Nuclear Gopher was born not as an act of rebellion but as a fairly innocent outgrowth of an innate passion for making music that we got from our mother, who got it from her parents.  We recorded our music because we made it.  We labelled it because it was fun to do so.  It wasn’t until we grew up that it ever occurred to us that it might be unusual to do this inside of our religion but even then, so what?  Unusual doesn’t mean wrong.  When I think of Nuclear Gopher I think of something born out of sharing something I love with people I love.  That was the origin and that’s still the point.

The other day it occurred to me that the most uncommon interest I have, the one I am least likely to get into a conversation at work about, is songwriting. I know plenty of other people who write songs, I play in a band with three of them, and I have a lot of songwriter friends but as far as “normal” people go, songwriting is not a common activity. You can’t just drop “so, I wrote a new song the other day” into casual office conversation and expect anybody to say “Oh really? Me too! Have you recorded a demo of it yet?”

I work with lots of people who play a musical instrument of some kind, piano or saxophone or guitar or violin, but they don’t compose new music, they just play music written by other people. I work with lots of people who enjoy music, who listen to it constantly, who can discuss it at length, but it never seems to occur to them to write any of their own.

Even my mom, from whom I inherited my musical talents, a woman who sang on stage semi-professionally for my entire childhood, is not a songwriter.

It’s mystifying to me because I’ve always written songs, quite naturally. It is so natural that for a long time I just assumed it was something that everybody did.

The first song I ever wrote that I still have a recording of is from kindergarten. I wrote (and recorded) a lot of songs in elementary school. They were mostly silly lyrics but I made sure even way back then that I had verses and choruses and melody and structure and rhythm. One song I wrote called “I’m Insane” even had several movements in different musical styles. When I listen to the recording today I’m kinda blown away by how musically sophisticated it is for a second grader. There is even a piano piece with no lyrics called “The Burner” that I wrote back then.

It’s not like it’s ever been easy. Even now, after having left a trail of over four decades worth of songs strewn in my wake, I still wrestle with the challenge of composing new music. I think of it like fishing for some sort of elusive species of fish. I go through all the trouble of waking up at dawn, loading up the boat, heading to the lake, and then I cast and cast and cast for hours without so much as a bite until I manage to land one. It’s lonely work and for every time I succeed in finding a song, there are a dozen where I get nothing or wind up with a song I don’t even particularly like.

If I’m being honest here I think it’s one thankless pursuit.

And yet, also being honest, it’s the thing I have the most pride in, the work I find the most personally rewarding. Songs I’ve written are also my anchors to important pieces of my past. When I hear a song I wrote, either as an actual recording or just playing in my head, I remember the time and place of my life when that composition happened and I relive pieces of my past. Sometimes it works the other way around, I remember something that happened to me and then a connected song comes into my mind. The times in my life when I let myself fall out of the songwriting practice are the ones where my memories get the fuzziest, the years that feel “lost” somehow. As if, failing to enshrine them in songs, I never really got a good mental record of what happened. Times in my life that I remember but don’t have songs for feel as if they could have happened to somebody else or as if I could have read about them in a book rather than having lived through them.

Even though I haven’t released much music of my own over the last several years, spending my time playing with other bands doing other music, I have written dozens of songs at home that will probably never be heard outside of my studio and my head. Even when I don’t perform or record my songs for other people, I still write them. I have to.

Weird, right? Of all my interests and pursuits, songwriting is easily the weirdest one, and yet there it is. A thing I do because I am compelled to do it.

Last night I mentioned to Esther that I had written a new song the other day. She asked about it, what was it called, what was it about, could I sing it to her, and so I pulled out an acoustic guitar and played it. After I was done she asked me to read the lyrics back to her again and told me that she thought they were really beautiful and that my lyrics are one of the best parts of my songs. I thanked her and felt a little flustered, showing a new song to another person (even one who I have known intimately for 18 years), is one of the only things I get legitimately nervous about. Most people don’t know how to respond to a new song. They either love it immediately (if it’s super catchy) or they listen without really hearing or absorbing. New songs from any source often take several listens to find their way into your brain and during those initial listens a person may not even know whether or not they like the song. They may just be absorbing it.  A lot of people struggle to internalize new music after they hit their 20’s so it’s a lot of ask of somebody, if you think about it.

If the source of the song is a person they know, they may feel as if a response is required of them, as if they need to say something about the song, “that’s really great” or “I liked it” but it’s kind of a lie because they probably don’t actually have an opinion yet. There is novelty and there is familiarity and a song that is catchy often gets you with the former while a song that stays with you often requires the latter. If I was the sort of songwriter who created a lot of catchy ditties that set toes a tappin’ it might be easier. Unfortunately(?) I’m the sort who often writes intellectual/emotional poetry set to guitars and drums. I am what I am. I have my “catchy pop tune” moments and I know them when I hear them, but they’re the exception rather than the rule so I have become used to keeping a lot my music to myself and avoiding putting people in the position of having to respond in real-time to my face. I prefer to record and release, thereby allowing the listener to engage with what I make on their own time and on their own terms without my awkward presence standing by.

It’s not as if I get a lot of negative responses. I’m happy to say that I’m objectively pretty good at songwriting. I’ve written some songs that are excellent and I know it. I’m a lifelong student of music of all genres and eras, I know the difference between good music and bad music and I’ve written both, but I’ve written more good than bad, which is nice. Writing music is a tough thing to do and it’s good to know that I’m good at it but that doesn’t help with the whole awkwardness thing when it comes to presenting it to other people.

It’s now 7:15 in the morning, I’ve been up with my coffee since 6:00, and most of that time has been spent writing this post. It’s the Tuesday after the long Memorial Day weekend and I need to be back at my job today, doing technology things, the work for which I have been paid in the filthy lucre of the realm for most of the last three decades. Most of my three day weekend was spent doing work around the homestead. I dug out and replaced a broken fence post that supported an automatic driveway gate, which I also repaired. I filled some gaps in a few retaining walls. I did some photography and developed and scanned a few rolls of film. And I composed drum parts for the new song I played for Esther last night. I’ve recorded two demos of it since I wrote it and I think I now know it well enough to attempt to track it for real this week.

I need to post this, jump in the shower, put on some clothes that aren’t pajamas, get a warm up of coffee and then I think I’ll head out to the studio and take a crack at writing another one before I turn myself back over to the world of corporate America. You never know, I might get lucky and catch a big fish before the morning stand-up meeting. A kid can dream, can’t he?

The legendary Lavone, me on the left, Rhett on the right

My elder brother, Rhett (1972-2005), was a musical prodigy who explored and experimented with music from pre-school until his untimely death from blood clots in his lungs at the ridiculously young age of 32. I grew up in his musical shadow and I constantly wonder what songs he would be making today if he was still here to make them.

I will be first to admit that although I loved my brother fiercely, I did not always understand him or where he was going with his music. For almost 20 years he and I formed the core of the experimental art-rock band The Lavone (which rhymes with “the phone” not “the fawn” in case you are wondering) and in that time we recorded 16 albums worth of lo-fi indie weirdo music that, it nothing else, amused the two of us immensely. Rhett and I often worked in a sort of alone/together process. We would independently write songs, sometimes more fully formed than others, and we would bring them to each other for completion and elucidation. I would usually take a guitar, figure out a few chords, write some lyrics, and bring the idea to Rhett who would fill in the drums and the rest of the production. Rhett usually worked in a more, shall we say, oblique way. Rhett would have the whole song in his head and would come to me and attempt, in vain, to get me to hear it too. He would play one or two chords, usually chords involving more fingers than it seemed he ought to have, and he would hum or sing a line or two, and then he would paint a verbal picture of the rest of what he was hearing and I would smile and nod and wait for the core of the recording to appear from one of his solo sessions on 4-track. Then he would play me the fleshed-out version and say “See!” and I would be completely incapable of connecting the thing I was hearing with the two chords I had heard a week previous but I would always be astonished.

Sadly for Rhett, he spent most of his musical life trying to stuff 48-track musical ideas into 4-track recording technology. Many of his recordings sound muddled and muffled, not because he intended them to, but because he had to bounce down so many tracks onto so many generations of tape in order to fit all the parts in his head on to the recording. He only spent the last 6 years of his life with access to modern digital audio workstation technologies and some of what he did with that freedom still gives me chills and I am one of the few people (perhaps the only one) who can hear his earlier recordings on tape while simultaneously hearing his full-color vision in my mind because, well, I was on the inside of his process.

It was recently suggested to me that I should create a curated playlist with commentary for the world and the idea appealed to me (although this is clearly not what Scott had in mind) so I have set myself the challenge of putting together 7 songs that highlight, for me, the things that made my brother’s music so powerful and influential in my life. Why 7? I don’t know. Seemed like a good choice for an arbitrary number. Are these his best songs? I don’t know. But they are songs that I have returned to over and over and over again for many many years.

1. Oh No – When Rhett was 16 he fell in love with a 29-year-old woman and she loved him back. This did not go over well with our parents and they stopped the two from seeing each other. Nothing physical ever transpired between them, but they were absolutely kindred spirits and when Rhett was cut off from her, his heart was shattered. I always found it interesting that as an adult Rhett ended up marrying a different woman who was also 13 years his senior. This first song, “Oh No”, was recorded in 1988 and appeared on one of the early albums by The Lavone recorded on a home stereo before we even had multi-track capability. Armed with only a Moog synthesizer, a guitar, bass, a drumset, a microphone, and a delay box, Rhett created a moody, sad, impassioned, ethereal, poem of a song that captured his teenage heartbreak. He played every instrument on this track via overdubbing, playing the drums first and then playing the keyboards along with onto a second tape, then adding the vocals and guitar onto yet another tape. This song was a staple of The Lavone and we performed it on stage at what turned out to be our final live performance in 2000. At that show, 12 years after he first laid it down, I finally got to play along with one of my favorite early Rhett songs. Years later I would record a cover for myself, but I give you here the original, The Lavone’s “Oh No”.

 

2. Hi, My Name Is Rhett Sutter – My second choice dates to 1991 which, at the time, seemed a lifetime from “Oh No”. “Hi…” appeared on The Lavone’s 1991 album “A Concert For No-One” and featured an older, wiser, 19-year-old Rhett attempting to paint a musical portrait of himself. Rhett started his musical life as a drummer so I always thought it was fascinating that his self-portrait at the time is set to the simple beat of a metronome and focuses instead on a sort of deranged carnival of synthesized sounds while he sings about how he sees himself versus the roles he plays versus how people interpret him and what he wants to be. This song has, to put it mildly, a lot going on. Despite the driving metronomic beat, almost nothing else ever repeats, there are few motifs, and around 6 minutes in the song appears to be fading out before storming back for some discordant piano notes. I remember him working on this one over the course of a few weeks. It is experimental and abstract, hardly a pop song, but it’s original title was “Here I Am” and he was attempting, to the best of his ability, to put the inside of his head on tape and if you surrender to the weirdness, this song is about as honest and compelling to me today as it was the first time he played it for me back in high school.


3. Gossip Gossip Gossip – I cannot even begin to describe how much I love it when Rhett growl-screams “really gets on my nerves / it’s cheesy / it’s lying and vain / all the stupid people / got nothing better to say / than gossip!” at the beginning of this song. It was the early 90’s, he was maybe 20 years old, and he here is just spewing beautiful venom at the top of his lungs over a sequence of truly diabolical chords that I could barely play. This song was recorded as part of our short-lived band Purple Triangles which brought Rhett and I into recording partnership with Chad Astleford and Sy Park. Unlike on most of the previous Lavone recordings, PT generally recorded as a foursome and so Rhett had to teach us to play his insane chords which he wrote on a piano and then looked up how to play on the guitar. This session he was a mad conductor, counting us in, writing out our parts, and literally guiding us through every twist and turn of the mini-symphony about the shallow vapidity of “all the stupid people”. All the Triangles sessions were fun, whether we were recording Sy’s brokenhearted power pop, or Chad’s blistering guitar solos, but the Gossip Gossip Gossip session was for me one of the purest joys of that year of recording. Rhett was so into it, such a studio tyrant, and I had no idea what the end result was going to be, only he did, and the final song still rocks my socks, I still think this is one of the quintessential Rhett vocal performances, and I’m still kinda mad at him for bending my fingers into all of those unnatural shapes.

4. Spiritually – Of all the fan mail we ever got back when NuclearGopher.com was a thing, two stick in my mind. The first favorably compared my brother Reed’s song “Melinda” to the Indigo Girls, which infuriated Reed to no end (he hated the Indigo Girls) and made me laugh hysterically. The second called this song, Spiritually, “the best song I have ever heard”. If I were forced at gunpoint to pick the most Rhett song of all the Rhett songs, this might be the winner. Recorded for his first released solo album “Rhett!”, this song has it all. Marvin Gaye-esque vocals, synth strings, slide guitars (I get chills around the 3-minute mark when they sweep in), unexpected chord changes, funky drumming, discordant soloing, and a surprise ending. I consider it all the more impressive when I consider that he wrote, performed, engineered, mixed, and mastered this thing all by himself using only a four-track tape player. Rhett was a deeply spiritual person who believed wholeheartedly in God. He didn’t usually write directly about this because the religion we were raised in frowned on that sort of direct messaging but he put it front and center on this track and that too, was Rhett. These songs are supposed to demonstrate some of his many different facets and so many of them are on display in Spiritually it really is quite a perfect showcase of who my brother was.

5. Floatin’ – On the final Lavone album, 2000’s Isotope, Rhett was finally unleashed from the confines of the 4-track and given all the tracks he could eat and he responded to this suddenly broad canvas by cramming 40+ tracks of audio into a pop symphony that weighs in at just over two minutes long. Saxophones, flutes, bass harmonicas, walls of voices, layers of percussion, banjo, this is the full Brian Wilson, the full Phil Spector, the full Polyphonic Spree, you can listen to it 30 times and find something you missed on every listen. I have now been listening to Floatin’ for 20 years and I still feel like the song is a rushing river that is pushing me, lifting me, tearing through a canyon, on-rushing, overwhelming me. He spent months on this one, bringing various people into the basement studio, teaching them the parts he needed them to play, borrowing instruments from friends, all to finally record that epic, towering, spectacle he had been aiming for all those years but lacked the technology to execute with this clarity and focus. He was so happy working on Floatin’ and he made a point of having each of us Sutter boys take a verse. Reed goes first, then Rhett takes the second verse, and then I get the third verse. I was honored.

6. Blues Around My Soul – If “Oh No” is representative of the early days of The Lavone, “Blues Around My Soul” is the perfect representative of the end. The final Rhett track on our final album, I have always thought of this song as the closing statement from The Lavone and therefore the end of an era of my partnership with my brother made all the more poignant for me by the fact that we had no idea that would be true at the time. Yes, we recorded a little more Lavone music over the next couple of years (one other song completes this list), but we never released another album together and most of our final recording sessions were lost to history. BAMS is a beautiful song with lush arrangements, beautiful harmonies, stirring chord changes, and an amazing vibe that makes me tear up every time I hear it. In this song Rhett was writing about his sadness over our mother’s deteriorating mental and emotional state at the time and the heavy toll it took on her relationships with us kids. He had long told me that he felt he was unable to connect emotionally with her, always felt abandoned and unloved, and he poured that into this song. It wasn’t his only work on the subject, but this one came at a particularly tough time for us all as she was beginning to suffer from the delusions and issues that would ultimately cause her to leave for parts unknown, never to be seen by any of us again. I don’t actually know where my mother is or if she is still alive and I can’t help but think on that while I listen to this one, knowing I will never hear either of their voices again.


7. Keep On Receiving Joy – Last but certainly not least, I choose “Keep On Receiving Joy”, from Rhett’s final album, Londa, recorded and released in 2004, the year before he died. This song was originally recorded as The Lavone and is actually the last released song that he and I worked on together. I contributed guitar and some backing vocals and the rest is pure Rhett. This song turned out perfect, IMO, but it’s development was a long and winding road featuring at least three alternate versions with completely different vocal and lyrics and at least one alternate title, Omens and Signs. We put in a lot of session time trying to get this one to match the picture in his head and when I edited together the photo montage for his funeral service, this was the song that concluded it. I really could see no better choice. This is a perfect song from his final album that perfectly reflects his tastes, his talents, and his beautiful soul and loving heart. Rhett could never have known that this would be among the final acts of musical creation of his life, but I know “Keep On Receiving Joy” encapsulates what he would want for anybody. Love. Joy. Peace. And harmony. Always harmony. Keep on receiving joy.

I had a bit of an epiphany last night.  I don’t know if it’s particularly profound, but I feel like my eyes were opened to a few truths that I have long known and simply forgotten to apply in my life.

First thing.  I have been a music person my entire life.  I have listened to music, thought in music, sang to myself in the car, in the shower, written my own songs, recorded music, performed music, learned instruments, collected music, obsessed over music.  I know people who maybe own two or three CDs and casually listen to Spotify, you know, normal people.   In contrast, I have literally thousands of albums in numerous formats: vinyl records, shellac 78s, CDs, cassettes, reel to reel tapes, digital files, you name it.  OK, I don’t have any 8-track carts, gotta draw the line somewhere, but I do actually own a functional hand-cranked Columbia Grafonola record player. 

I’ve personally been involved with and worked on the recording of at least 40 recorded albums or singles as either a performer, engineer, producer, or sometimes all of the above.  I have a recording studio in my basement.  I own dozens of musical instruments.  Guitars, basses, drum kits, keyboards, horns, accordions, slide whistles.  Hell, there is a documentary being made in which my musical endeavors and life’s work feature prominently. 

I say all of this to highlight the fact that you would be hard-pressed to find a person who’s life is more obviously centered around music, which makes it all the more strange to me that I’ve been so out of touch, emotionally and professionally, with music for the last few years. 

I have played in several bands and participated in the documentary, but I haven’t released a new album of original music since a minor acoustic EP that I recorded in a day back in December 2014.  I used to wonder if something was wrong with me if I didn’t release an album a year, at least, and I’m now coming up on six years with nothing to show for it except for the memories of some gigs played, a handful of unfinished projects and a few one-off songs or videos.  I have written and recorded things but I just haven’t been able to get into any sort of rhythm (pun intended) with my musical life.  I think that’s because I haven’t HAD a musical life.  Instead, I have been knee deep in the Miasma and it’s killed my sense of joy, wonder, and creativity.  At the same time, as a listener, I have allowed music to become a background wallpaper to my daily life instead of truly engaging with, appreciating it, eating, sleeping, and breathing it as I used to do.

The Miasma is a term I recently acquired from the book Fall; or, Dodge in Hell by author Neal Stephenson.  It is the catch-all term for the cultural wasteland of insanity, trolling, confirmation bias, misinformation, distortion, propaganda, bad blood, viral marketing, and lowest common denominator garbage that the modern internet has descended into.  Everything about the public discourse, the endless doomscrolling, the sheer end of the world nihilism of late stage capitalism, authoritarianism, stupidity, violence, and (bonus!) a global pandemic, it’s all so disheartening, so maddening, that turning on a television, reading a newspaper, looking at a social media feed, or visiting nearly any part of the internet for any reason is guaranteed to make whatever mood I am in worse.  Good moods become bad moods, bad moods become dire.

Instead of using music or meditation or poetry or art or any of the other tools at my disposal to counter the effects of the Miasma, I have fallen into an engagement trap based on the fact that, at one point, I used to love the internet.  I did.  I believed in it.  I thought it was a net-positive for humanity.  In the world before the web, communities were more physically isolated, knowledge harder to access, there was much more terra incognita.  The promise of the web and the connected digital society as laid out by luminaries like Ted Nelson, Vannevar Bush, Nicholas Negroponte, Alan Kay, and even Steve Jobs was so appealing.  It was almost like a second Enlightenment Age dawning.  All the worlds knowledge available, all the communications barriers broken.  How could this be anything other than an Objectively Good Thing?

Well, as it turns out, every silver lining has a cloud.  As it turns out, people were not historically hostile and tribal merely because of limited communications technology or limited access to information.  People are hostile and tribal because they have been made that way through billions of years of natural selection.  They require almost no incentive whatsoever to pick sides and develop animosity towards each other.  Kurt Vonnegut nailed it with his granfalloon concept.  Thanks to this programming, hyper-connecting all the people was always going to mean that the people who thrive on rancor, discord, and negativity would have louder voices and more power to shape our culture than they did before.  Capitalism, which naturally goes where the market leads, would naturally find ways to monetize and stoke this hostility and division in order to make money.  Religions and political parties would do the same, feeding the flames to advance power and agendas.  These are not new forces in human society, they existed as far back as written history records and likely much further back.  It turns out that the previous limits imposed by geography, technology, and access to information were also holding some of our tribalism and collective insanity in check by channeling it into narrow and somewhat isolated outlets.  That is no longer possible.  Thanks to the democratizing power of the internet, we now have all of the foibles and ridiculousness of our species running amok, unfettered, unchecked by any force, Enlightenment 2: Electric Boogaloo has given way to Idiocracy 2: Boogaloo Now Means Race War.

But wait a minute, I hear you saying, wasn’t this post about music?  Yeah, yeah, I’m getting there, it’s my blog, I wanna take a while to get to my point, that’s my prerogative.  Keep your shirt on.

OK, so, the Miasma was probably inevitable, in retrospect, but I didn’t anticipate it.  I believed, perhaps too strongly, in the positive and empowering aspects of the always on, hyper-connected, society.  I thought it would lead me to more creativity (more ability to share what you create is good, right?), more human connection (all my old friends are here, that’s gotta be good, right?), and all the old hassles of primitive technologies would be rendered obsolete by the wireless, simple, one device to rule them all vision of the smartphone as digital camera, digital music player, GPS, movie player, social life, VR headset, internet information appliance, dessert topping, floor wax, etc.   I was an early adopter.  I was a proponent.  I was a fan. 

I was wrong.

The all-in-one device is a marvel of convenience, but it makes focused attention on any one single thing of value extremely challenging.  Always being connected is great for knowing where to find a gas station while driving in an unknown area or for settling a bet about a piece of trivia with a friend, but it creates a constant psychological drag on the real world experience of every day life because you often feel compelled to use it just because it’s there and you’re bored for 5 whole consecutive seconds.  A globally connected platform for delivering creative work to audiences is theoretically empowering for artists, but since everybody throws everything out there, nothing feels special or unique or lasting, almost everything feels ephemeral, transitive, meaningless, like a night at an open-mic where the entire audience is on-stage at once, talking at the same time. 

In the Miasma, all of these things that hypothetically could have been enriching, empowering, and inspiring have mostly turned to shit.  Devalued, corrupted, monetized, destroyed, and we as a society have been lessened to the extent where Donald Fucking Trump actually became President of the United States.  Think about that.  As far back as the 80’s that would have been the punchline to a joke about America failing as a country and IT.  ACTUALLY.  HAPPENED.

I can chart my decline in creative interest and output on a graph (yes, I’ve actually done this on paper) and it directly correlates to the rise of the post-Facebook/post-iPhone Miasma version of the internet.  My flagging interest in saying anything whatsoever to the world at large, my increasing disinterest in my OWN MUSICAL WORK, my general sense of despondency about anything, or anyone, anywhere, truly mattering at all, my ever deeper struggles with the blank page or blank tape, it all correlates perfectly to the amount of time I have spent online since the New Enlightenment turned into the Miasma. 

The question is, what is a boy to do?

The internet I fell in love with is gone, for good.  The world I grew up in is radically changed.  No use looking backwards, it is what it is. I can limit my online time, work on my mindfulness, and swear a lot, but it I can’t undo what’s been done.  This is where my job is.  This is where my friends are.  This is how the music and tech industries function.  If I want to work in technology and/or be a creative, I can’t pretend the cultural landscape is what it was 12 years ago. 

I think the answer, ironically(?), is hinted at in trends I am beginning to encounter in the habits of the generation being raised with hyper-connectivity and social networking since childhood.  They are not enamored of apps and smartthings, they don’t think they’re especially cool or interesting, and they don’t inherently think the digital stuff is better or worse than what came before it.  It’s all just tech.  This is why a lot of people these days are, apparently, rediscovering mixtapes made with actual cassettes.  I did not foresee cassettes coming back, but they are.  Why?  Making mix tapes with your own voice and choices of songs was fun when I was a kid and it’s still fun now.  Who cares that you can listen to the same songs on your phone on Spotify?  That doesn’t feel unique like a tape does.  Another example, my niece became obsessed with typewriters at age 12 despite having a smartphone and tablet.  People who didn’t experience the migration from analog to digital to networked are not inherently biased against the old tools and can even appreciate their quirks and limits but mostly they appreciate the physicality, the reality, of analog. 

The Miasma is an endless stream of mostly negative messages masquerading as news, relationships, and information which is tailored to hook you, personally, and to shape your world and your view of it.  Unconnected technology only puts out what you put into it, there is no agenda, no secret influencers.  Maybe the way to get creative again is, in part, to only use tools and technologies that don’t try to influence my behaviors. 

And while I do think that’s a part of it, the real insight I had is that the flip side of the Miasma is how it makes you, me, everybody who participates, into both influenced and influencer.  We are all trying to culturally signify our alignments, beliefs, and affiliations.  We are all posting selfies and liking posts and crafting a semi-public persona as a type of performance art.  This is not an environment that fosters or encourages actual creativity.  In fact, it’s an active impediment because it creates the illusion of creativity.

Taking a photograph and applying some funny filter to it or cobbling together a meme is an act of creation, sure, but it’s more craft than art.  It’s more like making a hand-print turkey painting than it is like writing a confessional poem.  These types of minor creative output are mostly imitative or derivative, and the primary value is amusing other people.  These are all performance, but not all art is performance.

I recently read something written by Jeff Buckley in the liner notes to the posthumously released collection of material he was working on at the time of his death “Sketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk”.  He wrote the following about his songwriting:

There is also music I’ll make that will never-ever-ever be for sale. This is my music alone, this is my true home; from which all things are born and from which all my life will spring untainted and unworried, fully of my own body.

And this is something I have known for a very long time but I have let myself forget, the simple basic fact that you need to create first and foremost for your ears alone, for your heart alone, for your soul alone, if you want to have a home to share with others.  You can’t make that kind of art with the thoughts, feelings, opinions, or judgments of other people in mind.  You can’t be wondering if they will like you or what you have to say.  It’s not about them.  It’s the opposite of performance.  It’s self-exploration.  The more my life has become about the performances and manipulations of the Miasma, the more I’ve come to critically judge my own work and the less free I have felt to just play, explore, experiment, and enjoy the process of making music that nobody will ever hear.  I’ve been laboring under the false feeling that if I make music that I don’t think is “releasable” then I shouldn’t have bothered to make it.  When I was in high school sitting cross-legged on my bed with a four-track recorder recording ambient soundscapes about Tony Bennett or swarms of bees I wasn’t worrying about anybody hearing me or caring what I was doing…  I was having fun.

Fun.  Yes, fucking FUN.  Where is fun in 2020?  Where is joy in 2020?  Where is there joy to be found in the endless doomscroll of the Miasma or the viral marketing hellscape or the endless disgusting behavior of the bigots and fundamentalists or the constant manipulation of influencers and trends and memes and the barrage of messages and notifications and micro and macro time sinks of modern life?  I’ll tell you where it is.  Nowhere.  Missing in action.

And there, ladies and gentlemen, there is the key in all of this navel gazing.  Without fun, without joy, even the joy of painful catharsis (and yes, there is joy to be found in working through painful emotions, just think of the joy of relief when you remove a really bad splinter), what are you sharing?  What have you got other than an empty “look at me”? 

I’ve let the Miasma train me.  I’ve let it get me focused on publishing, producing, consuming and being consumed, constantly trying to drink a bottomless pool dry, and neglecting the square one of unplugging, playing, doing things just because they are interesting, making music for nobody else to hear, remembering that the bad news will still be there whether you look at it or not but that your soul won’t be if you won’t look after it.  When was the last time I just put on a record and listened to it without also being online?  When the last time I picked up a guitar and just made something up with no plan?  When was the last time I turned away from all screens, tablet, television, phone or e-reader, and just lived in the world of the actual senses? 

I am not sure.  I know that my entire life was spent in real space up to a point, and then it started digitizing, and it eventually wound up twisted around this shared online fiction we now call a culture, but the answer is not about “going back”, it’s not about “disconnecting”, it’s about remembering that the Miasma cannot provide meaning, it cannot provide true joy, but music can, real life can, and if I want to find that again, I need only remember how to play, how to write for myself and myself alone, and then to make a conscious decision to stop participating in the endless performance.

That’s a lot of knobs and sliders and wires…

I haven’t released a new album since The Coal Room EP in December of 2014 but that doesn’t mean I haven’t been musically active. The last six years have been rather productive, actually. I spent some time as a member of the band Robots From the Future, also a stint in the band Fistful of Data’s, I played a handful of solo sets, I released a couple singles with music videos, I sat in on drums for a couple “adult jam” style gigs with friends, and then I joined up with my current band, Awkward Bodies and we have played some great shows and released a few singles as well. Still, I have missed being a recording artist unto myself so this year I hope to change that a little.

I’ve accumulated a bit of a backlog of solo material, enough for more than one album. I’ve winnowed the list down to a decent dozen or so and I expect that I may just start working my way through recording them. It’s no exaggeration to say I’m overdue for a legit solo album.

Since I was in sixth grade I’ve always been involved in one band or musical project or something and have only had a few years where I didn’t at least appear on some sort of recording that was distributed for public consumption in some way. Last year I appeared on three Awkward Bodies singles, the year before that I released a video single for one of own songs, Ostrich, but 2015-2017 was a three year dry spell right on the heels of The Coal Room (and the rather obscure RFTF single “Bloody Baby” which appeared on a comp). And that’s OK. I’m at peace with it. During that time I took some sax lessons, I played shows in a few bands, I kitted out a new studio at a new house, I wrote and recorded new music, I was involved in a pretty cool upcoming Nuclear Gopher documentary… basically, I was very active, just not in the recording arena. But I miss it.

Just this week, I had a recording session with Lemuel “Ace” Herlihy (Michael Heuer) for what will (hopefully) be a followup to our 2014 ambient/experimental/noise smash hit album “Nininger”. The mess in the photo above is from the session. That was really fun and if all goes according to plan we should see that record done in time to submit it for this year’s RPM Challenge. I’m thinking we should call it “Nininger 2: Electric Boogaloo (Return of Ignatius Donnelly)”.Awkward Bodies has been an extremely rewarding experience and tonight we will be having our first practice with our new lineup. Lem Herlihy and I will get together again next week, I hope, and maybe, just maybe, I’ll do what I did with The Coal Room and lavoneloveletter and just take a single session to get the bones of whole new album laid down and then finish it off with overdubs over the course of a few weeks/months. I have the songs. What is stopping me?

My mother was singing in a band when I was in the womb which means that my first time on stage with a band was before I breathed air.  I think that pretty much doomed me to the life of a musician.  Granted, I realized early on that the musician thing wasn’t particularly lucrative so I started a career in software development to pay the bills, and it has done so admirably for my entire adult life, but I continue to do the musician thing.  By my count, I’ve been involved in the production of over 40 different cassettes, CD’s or digital music releases as either a songwriter, musician, engineer or producer and I still love it.  Performing and recording music is a central thread in my life’s story.

Today I am planning a new recording studio and developing material for a couple of new recording projects, but this morning I keep pondering how I got here and what all those previous music projects actually mean to me.  Why keep doing this?  Clearly it’s not to “make it big” or become rich and famous.  So, why?  The answer differs from recording to recording.

The earliest recordings made by my brothers and I were strictly kids playing at making music, at least for me.  But that early playground led to a lifelong passion for all of us, so it’s hard to dismiss.  Rhett was first to blossom when he turned out to be a childhood drumming phenom.  I took a few more years to start figuring out guitar and songwriting throughout middle school and high school.  By the time I turned 20, though, I had learned multi-track recording, audio engineering fundamentals, multiple instruments, songwriting, and the lot.  I had matured from a kid singing in the basement into a young man who was serious about being a musician.  I think of all those early albums recorded in school as an extension and maturation of the learning process that started as soon as our hands were big enough to hold instruments.

Throughout my 20’s, I was learning a whole different skill set.  How to be an adult.  How to raise a child.  How to manage money and build a career.  I feared that I would lose sight of making music.  I feared that the creative spark would be overwhelmed by “real life” and I would be one of those guys who looked back nostalgically on the “good old days”.  It almost happened.  Maybe it would have, but I never let that idea of myself as a creative person disappear from my mind.  As I learned to develop computer software I used the technical skills I developed to work on building an online record label.  I learned how to use digital audio workstations to record and produce music instead of older analog 4-track equipment.  Eventually my brother died, our band ended, I went through some major life transitions, my indie label folded, and music took on a whole new role of safety net and survival mechanism.  I recorded a bunch of solo material and you can find it here on this site.

Through all of this, music has helped me bond with my brothers and with friends, given me an outlet to say things that I couldn’t say any other way, provided me with a constructive domain in which to apply other skills as I learned them, served as a psychological health practice, and (of course) it has been a lot of fun.  It is also incredibly satisfying that so much of the music I’ve been involved with is recorded.  It’s like I have most of my life on tape in one way or another.

I can listen to myself at age 8, singing the first song I ever wrote while my brother drums in the background.  Or at age 14 when I wrote the first song I really felt proud of.  There I am in high school falling in love.  There I am in my 20’s celebrating the birth of my son.  I can go online right now and hear my 30 year old self losing his religion and his brother and his grip on the life he thought he was living.  It’s all documented in this strange, mostly public, way.  I am keenly aware that the music I write and record today will be heard by my future self and will bring the thoughts, fears, feelings, desires, and circumstances of my current life to his mind more than any photograph or video can do.  It’s like a diary plus a photo album but with the intimacy of encoded thoughts and a spoken voice and the awareness on my part of exactly what it all meant to me at the time.

When I think about the music I am making right now, I’m not thinking of posterity or my future self or entertaining anybody or making money or getting famous.  I’m just saying what I find within myself to say, when I go looking.  I’m casting around for feelings and thoughts, listening to my own mind for snatches of melodies that I might want to use, giving myself subconscious commands, sketching melodies or words with instrument or writing utensil in hand, digging around for something that inspires me to hit record.  I do this now because it’s what I’ve done for so long that I don’t feel like myself if I don’t.  I really am doomed.  And I think that’s OK.

1.jpg

About six months ago I was on Facebook and I noticed a post from my friend Liz about a 90’s cover band. I said it sounded like fun. That Saturday, we had our first practice.

I had previously been in the band Robots From the Future with Liz’s husband Keith. In fact, I was singing and playing the guitar for them as they took their vows on-stage at the Kitty Kat Club at the end of a Robots set which happened to also be their wedding. Liz had started taking drum lessons and really wanted a band to play in so she could have a reason to keep practicing and playing. Keith was already on-board on guitars so I volunteered to play bass and keyboards. There was an obligatory “Craig’s List Guy” who showed up for the first practice (I was late, I missed him, he wasn’t invited back) and there was one more person to join the trio of myself, Liz, and Keith, a young man named Cristhian Arias-Romero who was a friend of a friend and came highly recommended as a singer and performer.

For the first few practices we brainstormed 90’s songs we loved. We all came at it from different angles. Keith was suggesting things like They Might Be Giants and Ween, I was throwing out Elliot Smith and Jeff Buckley, Cris was pushing Britney Spears and Madonna, Liz was voting for Cake and Fresh Prince, it was a great mash up of music from different genres and years, like a tornado in a Sam Goody store circa 1999. I found myself thinking that this could be a fun band to be in. Not only did I already like Liz and Keith, but Cris was really a great guy too, the chemistry was fantastic from the beginning. If that could be combined with a band that could play a wide range of music and make it our own, maybe being in a “cover band” wouldn’t be so bad.

Cuz I gotta admit… I came into the band with a bit of a bias. I have always considered cover bands to be somehow lesser. It’s not like the musicians aren’t good, or the songs, it’s just that I associate cover bands with background music at weddings or fawning tributes to better bands. It was hard for me to mentally connect the words “creativity” and “cover band”. It’s like, “get your own ideas” or “the original artist did it better, why are you appropriating their stuff?” They’ve always seemed lazy to me and I’ve never been in a proper cover band before. Oh sure, I used to jam on the weekends with some guys and we pretty much just played Neil Young songs, but we never gigged and we didn’t take it all that seriously. It was just something to do.

So, joining a 90’s cover band? Really? I’m doing that now? And we named ourselves after a Star Trek TNG episode? Really??

4.jpg

Well, I got past my initial skepticism and started to enjoy myself and before long we had our first gig on the calendar, a night at the Eagles Club playing for the 90’s Preservation Society. It was the perfect place to kick-off a 90’s cover band and the first gig went remarkably well. We flubbed some notes and there were nerves, but the crowd was really responsive and Cris was such a natural showman that nobody cared. He was dancing and belting out the “jams” and really selling it and it was electric. Keith and Liz and I were pretty solid as a unit. It was crazy fun. That was when I really realized there was something to this band. We weren’t just playing 90’s songs, even from that first show we were a little theatrical, we were making the songs different and owning them.

2

There have been many conversations over margaritas and pizza at band practices about how cover bands are perceived. How many people in the music community look down on you if you “just play covers”. Some people don’t want to book you. Some of the people that DO want to book you only want you to be a radio made of meat. We’re a theatrical band that happens to play 90’s songs, not a tribute to Pearl Jam or background music for a bar mitzvah. Getting shows lined up was a little challenging at first, but a few made their way onto the calendar. One of our next shows was at Palmer’s Bar, which, frankly, is not generally considered to be a venue that most bands even want to play. Palmer’s is a dive bar with a stage about the size of a king size bed. Most of the people I told about our pending gig at Palmer’s used words like “stabbing” or “shooting” in their remarks in re: The Venue.

However, we were offered the gig and we took the gig and we rocked the shit out of Palmer’s, tiny stage and all. Nobody was shot or stabbed, and we were invited back, and we went back, and it was awesome again, and we are going back again later this month.

5

During the summer I actually played a few solo sets too. I did a night at Acadia and I played acoustic guitar for a dog rescue event on the government plaza in downtown Minneapolis, but FoD just kept getting better and more fun. I was offered the chance to play a fund-raiser carnival for Safe Hands Animal Rescue and I turned it into a FoD gig.

By the time we played the doggy carnival we were really starting to gel as a band. Cris showed up to that one wearing a homemade pink poodle outfit and it was going awesome until we got rained out and had to cut our second set short after only two songs.

6

Weekly practices, a few bar gigs, the 90’s Preservation Society, a dog rescue carnival, it was a busy first six months for our band, at least by my standards. I’ve never been in bands that play out on a regular basis. Most of my background is in writing and recording. This was getting to be a really fun time. And people were noticing. And then… sadly… Cris told us that he was going to be moving to Seattle.

This was a blow. I am happy for him, and his reasons are really solid, but we were just really turning into a really unique, creative, and interesting band… that happens to play covers. And we had three pending gigs on the calendar. And without Cris being a larger than life presence up front, it wasn’t sure how we could still be a cover band without turning into the stereotypical outfit.

Our next gig, the last one with Cris, was the 10th Brainniversary of the Winona Zombie Crawl, and it happened last Saturday.

This gig was special for a few reasons. One, we were playing both the opening and closing sets of the night bookending the acts Speshul K and Koo Koo Kanga Roo. Second, it was a road trip, Winona being something like 120 miles from my house, so we rented a trailer and got a hotel room for the night. Third, it was a freaking ZOMBIE CRAWL so we all went in costume. Last but not least, it was the last show with Cris without whom, it’s safe to say, we would not be the band we are.

The band all met up at my place around 1:00 in the afternoon where we ran through a couple songs, ate a pizza, and basically got loosened up. Then we went to the U-Haul place and got the trailer and came back and loaded up. The trip to Winona was beautiful, country roads with corn fields, perfect early-fall-late-summer weather, then the bluffs of southeastern Minnesota and the Mighty Mississippi River in the Lake City-Pepin-Wabasha area. We checked into our hotel, contemplated “food lamps”, and Liz and Cris worked on their makeup and Keith got into his robot zombie outfit. I think the kid behind the check-in desk at the Super 8 was crushing on Liz a little.

wzc10-5.jpg

Keith and I went ahead to Ed’s (No Name) Bar, our home for the evening, and unloaded drums and keyboards and guitars and amps and all that good stuff. Our sound guy was Rob and he helped us do the usual “plug this thingie in over there” action. Actually, side note, Rob did a great job and I heard from a few people that the sound was excellent, so thanks Rob!

wzc10-4.jpg

Eventually Liz and Cris joined us and we sound checked and stuff. Cris commanded quite a bit of attention as a 6 foot 6 cross-dressing nun, Liz had a bloody hammer, a bloody knife, and a severed head on a hook, Keith was silver with a rectangular scrotum, and I was an undead Lego man. All in all, not the usual Saturday night.

10

As we started our first set around 9:15 the crowd started to filter in. It was starting to be good times but then we were afraid we would cut into the next act’s time so we cut it a little short. I loved getting a warm-up set like that. It was really nice and I think it set us up well for the closer.

Speshul K, the first rapper I’ve ever seen wearing a pink bathrobe on stage, did a set after ours, and then Koo Koo Kanga Roo got up and turned the whole place into the weirdest Saturday morning kids show you’ve ever seen. There were zombies everywhere, and a rainbow parachute, and a big sign, and lots of dancing, and pumping beats, and comic books, and Jello brain molds, and cake, and the place really got going. So much so, in fact, that I worried about going on and losing the crowd. The bar was set absurdly high. We had our work cut out for us.

9

We started off with Poison by Bell Biv Devoe, and any doubts I had were quickly erased. The crowd was raucous. They loved us. They were singing along, dancing, loving everything. They stayed even though it was the midnight set. Cris was amazing, Liz and Keith and I were tight, and every song we played seemed to go better than the last one. By the time we finished with Jeff Buckley’s “Lover You Should’ve Come Over” and Komeda’s “Boogie Woogie Rock n Roll” I was in heaven. It was the most fun I could remember having playing a set. We had a big on-stage group hug and there were tears and it was just…

It was one of those moments you remember for the rest of your life.

It felt like the entire band was leading up to that.

I’ve played music my whole life, and disdained cover bands, and this was truly special. Standing on stage, in a group hug with a robot, a zombie slayer and a nun in front of a room full of drunken zombies, dressed as a Lego. Not something I could have foreseen.

8

I’ve got a lot of memories from this year, but this one is gonna stick.  We were Fistful of Datas.

7

But lest you think this is goodbye…  Fistful of Datas isn’t over. A parting gift to us from Cris was an introduction to another singer, Mike, who will no doubt be amazing as well. But I think it’s safe to say that Chapter 1 of the story of the band is written, Chapter 2 is just starting, and I no longer hate cover bands. At least, not this one.

11