May 22, 2008
RyanSutter.Net’s 700th Post!
This morning I tried riding my bike to the bus and taking it with me for the first time using the bike rack on the front of the bus. Two things to note: 1) I’m a moron for not doing this sooner and 2) I have no idea what the damn combination is to my bike lock. I’m sure I’ll figure it out, but as it is… grrr.
Last night I was in a long conversation via IM with a Witness girl from another state who found my blog over the Internet. She was DF’d a while ago and then started researching the Watchtower Society and started uncovering all their dirty laundry (membership in the UN, Creation book dishonesty, 587v607, the works). She really wants to present her findings to her parents in an attempt to open their eyes to the dishonesty and hypocrisy within the Watchtower Society because they’re both really good people and she believes they would want to be aware if they were being mislead.
I’ve been trying to help her as much as possible over the last few weeks in large part because (holy smokes, the entire bus suddenly smells like pot… methinks somebody has been up to something this morning and just got on the bus… whew…. I mean it smells like a freakin’ field of pot on a sunny day), sorry to digress there… where was I, oh yeah, I’ve been trying to help because I feel like maybe if I we can develop some sort of effective strategy with them, there is a chance with my family.
She tried asking her mother to study with her but her mom said that any studying should be done with the elders from the judicial committee. They haven’t spoken to their daughter in over a year and now they are at least agreeing to talk to her in a week. She has hopes that she’ll be able to present her case when they talk and I wish her the best. My hopes aren’t high though. The amount of mental insulation around the thought processes of a Jehovah’s Witness is truly astonishing.
Let’s look at the box they are in, eh? They have been told that the entire world lies in the power of Satan the Devil. Everything. Business, governments, schools, all secular institutions. They distrust anything that is not explicitly endorsed by the Watchtower Society. If the Society says that all historians who disagree with something they claim are just trying to discredit the Bible and further their evolutionary/atheist agenda, then everything those historians say is immediately unusable in a conversation with a Witness because the Witness will assume that if it appears there is evidence in support of the alternate view, Satan is responsible for it, and otherwise it’s just God-dishonoring worldly garbage. This means that when attempting reasoning with a Witness your best bets are the Bible and the Watchtower Society publications, their two trusted sources of information.
The big problem there, of course, is that the insulated against problems found in those places as well. The Bible they use, the New World Translation, has been meticulously revised over the last 50+ years to erase most of the controversial material, obvious contradictions and the like. If you are able to illustrate a contradiction or problem using another Bible translation, they may be able to just blame the “worldly” translators (don’t forget, other Christian denominations are also under Satan’s control). If you are able to illustrate it using only the NWT, they’ll just say you are twisting things which only proves that you’re an apostate. You see then, they are in a perfect cocoon, one they can only escape through their own efforts. External information is irrelevant, and internal contradictions and conflicts are resolved in a number of ways. If it’s a matter of a teaching formerly espoused by the Society that is crazy (such as the idea that aluminum cookware is dangerous and evil) they will simply say, “We don’t believe that anymore. I know the Society has made mistakes in the past, but they’ve corrected them. That is part of why I trust them. They are progressively gaining brighter light on the Truth.” If the problem is a current issue they have two options, accuse you of twisting the Society’s words or, if it’s so obvious that they can’t even do that, they can say, “I know they aren’t perfect, maybe they will get new light on this in the future. It doesn’t invalidate all the things they are right about.”
There is no way for reason to stick it’s head in the door with a Witness. This is why they are not a normal religion and are instead a cult. Only cults make a point of training their members to reject all but approved sources of information. Typically cults do this by physically isolating their members, but the Witnesses can’t do that because they’re an evangelizing cult and their members need to be out in the world in general. So, they psychologically isolate their members by constructing a little mental box that constrains what information they are allowed to pay attention to and gives them what seems like plausible reasons to deny information that contradicts what they believe. I honestly do not know which technique is more effective. A cultist like those polygamists in Texas lives a life of a kind of forced isolation, cut off from the world by their community so extremely that they most likely don’t even know what’s out there. The Witnesses have to encounter “the world” every day, they live in it, work in it, see things on the news, and they have to develop strong internal controls to avoid being affected by it. On the plus side, they get to live fuller lives then physically isolated cultists, on the negative side they have far more convoluted mental processes. It’s much easier to maintain the illusion of us and them, black and white, when you never see the grey areas. Witnesses certainly do and it leads to a lot of internal conflict.
I really hope against hope that there is a way to talk reason to a truly believing Witness but in the meantime, since it seems there is not, I just have to keep looking for a gap in the insulation.





